Plaintiff Forced to Drop Major Case Mid-Trial

April 26, 2011 in News

After concluding her evidence and in the midst of hearing the presiding judge announce from the bench the reasons he was going to dismiss her case, a Virginia plaintiff was forced to nonsuit her claims even before the defense began its case.

The case involved a young lady rendered a quadriplegic in a single vehicle rollover.  The plaintiff presented evidence from two well-heeled experts that the vehicle was defective and that the defect caused the plaintiff’s injuries.  Unfortunately, their testimony did not pass Virginia’s prohibitions against conclusory testimony that is unsupported by facts and science.  Although it was clear to everyone in the courtroom (including, we later learned, the jurors) but plaintiff’s counsel that the proof was not getting past the legal threshold, the plaintiff’s team failed to retool and make out a prima facie case.

The nonsuit, which Virginia plaintiffs have an unfettered right to exercise until the moment the axe comes down, gives the plaintiff a right to start all over and try again.

One of the more gratifying events of the trial came when, after the jurors were discharged, one of them sought to hire us to represent him.

The Spencer LLP trial team consisted of Chris Spencer, Elizabeth Shoenfeld and Tracey Turner, with remote support from Susan White, Sandy Treakle and Ellen Begren.